Raise the bar: 16 years after the bar-bender strike

5 mins read

In the summer of 2007, more than a thousand bar-benders fought for their rights. The 36-day strike was the largest strike in Hong Kong’s history at the time. The workers successfully pushed for better pay and decreased working hours.

Yet, the significance of the strike extended well beyond these successes. The bar-benders turned a new page for the Hong Kong independent labour movement when they took to the streets. 16 years have passed since then, but the bar-bender strike remains as inspiring as ever, particularly at a time when the independent labour movement is facing unprecedented repression in the city.

36 days of strike: 8/8–12/9/2007

In August 2007, 200 bar-benders kicked off their 36-day strike with a mass protest outside a luxury apartment construction site in To Kwa Wan.

The bar-benders had been facing pay cuts since 1997 as a result of the financial crisis and the SARS pandemic. In 1997, a bar bender earned HK$1,200 for an eight-hour day of arduous work. However, in 2007, they only earned HK$800 for an 8.5-hour workday. The bar-benders demanded a modest pay raise to HK$950 per day, as well as a return to an eight-hour workday. However, the employers’ association, the Hong Kong Bar-Bending Contractors Association, rejected the workers’ proposal. The tone-deaf response from their employers was the final straw, consequently triggering a walkout.

The strike was first led by the bar-benders’ union affiliated with the pro-China Hong Kong Federation of Trade Unions (HKFTU). On 13 August, the Hong Kong Bar-Bending Contractors Association proposed a gradual pay raise starting from HK$850/day and increasing to HK$950/day by the following year. The proposal fell well short of the demands of the bar-benders and negotiations broke down. Instead of supporting the workers, the pro-China federation asked the bar-benders to call off the strike. The striking workers were infuriated by the betrayal.

‘Strong enough to raise a steel bar but not a family’

The Hong Kong Confederation of Trade Unions (HKCTU), on the other hand, remained a strong ally to the workers. They assisted striking workers in electing representatives for the strike and provided guidance along the way. At the peak of the strike, workers from over 80 construction sites had joined, effectively paralysing major construction projects in the city.

During the 36-day strike, the workers organised two protests, one with 1,500 participants and the other with 2,500. Original slogans from these protests such as ‘Go on strike, Persist to the end!’, ‘Bar-benders are Heroes! No Us, No Prosperity!’, and ‘Strong enough to raise a steel bar, but not a family’ are still widely used in workers’ strikes today.

‘Strong enough to raise a steel bar but not a family’. A bar bender holding a poster during the strike.

Raise the bar: For the industry and the labour movement at large 

The strike officially concluded on 12 September after 36 days of negotiation between the workers and the employers. The bar-benders were able to negotiate a wage increase to HK$860, around HK$10 higher than the amount proposed by the employer. However, the achievement of the bar-bender movement goes beyond just a wage increase. The striking workers also successfully called for a standardised 8-hour workday in the industry, and the movement itself brought bar-benders together to form an independent trade union to counter the HKFTU. The bar-bender union also established regular meetings with the employers to negotiate salary and benefits, which significantly boosted their bargaining power. In 2022, a skilled bar bender could earn HK$2,600 a day.

A model for future strikes 

A solidarity fund was established to aid the striking bar-bender in Hong Kong during the strike. It was the A solidarity fund was established to aid the bar-benders on strike in Hong Kong. It was the first solidarity fund ever set up in the city. Over 40 organisations joined together to form the United Front for Supporting the Bar-benders’ Strike. They took turns delivering petitions to various property developers, relaying the bar-benders’ demands. The strike gained significant traction in civil society locally and globally, made evident by the receipt of solidarity messages from trade unions around the world. The strike served as a model for the subsequent Dockers’ Strike and the Hoi Lai Estate Cleaners’ Strike that later happened in 2013 and 2017, respectively.

Persist until the end, the victory will be ours.

Lee Cheuk-Yan, former General Secretary of HKCTU

‘Persist until the end, the victory will be ours’. Lee Cheuk-Yan, the former General Secretary of HKCTU, first said this at a bar-benders’ rally on 19 August, when their employers were being deafeningly silent to their demands. Despite this silence, the workers’ persistence and unity brought them to triumph, which is a timely reminder, especially for Hong Kongers living under the authoritarian regime today.

] A bar bender on strike holding a poster with the slogan ‘Bar-benders have got the power’.

Timeline: 36-day Bar-bender Strike in 2007 

8 August           200 bar-benders gathered outside a construction site in To Kwa Wan, demanding a pay raise from HK$800/day to HK$900/day and a reduction of working hours to eight hours per day. The demands were rejected by the employers.

9 August           A rally with 500 participants, followed by 200 workers protesting outside the Government House while over 20 others marched into the office of the Hong Kong Bar-Bending Contractors Association.

10 August         600 workers marched to Central under a Signal 8 typhoon warning. The march was halted by the police. The workers then staged a three-hour sit-in protest at Yau Ma Tei MTR station.

11 August         300 workers blocked traffic on Queen’s Road and Ice House Street in Central after the then-Secretary for Labour and Welfare Matthew Cheung declined multiple meeting requests. Traffic was disrupted for three hours.

13 August         In the morning, the steel workers’ organisation, the HKFTU, started negotiations with the Hong Kong Bar-Bending Contractors Association. The association agreed to raise the daily salary to HK$850, with a further increase to HK$950 by the following August. The association also agreed to introduce a 15-minute break in the morning of each workday. However, the offer was rejected by workers and the talks broke down. The HKFTU then called the workers to disperse and end the strike, which led to them being accused of betraying the workers.

19 August         1,500 workers marched to the Central Government Offices.

20 August         A solidarity fund was set up and received public donations.

24 August         The solidarity fund raised HK$460,000. The 1,200 striking workers received HK$300 each.

25 August         Over 40 civil society organisations joined forces and set up the United Front for Supporting the Bar-benders’ Strike.

26 August         2,500 people marched to support the strike.

31 August         Negotiations resumed. The workers’ representatives walked out as no consensus was reached.

2 September     Workers organised a protest outside the Central Government Offices for the second time.

3 September     The protest continued. Workers gathered at the headquarters of the Labour Department in Sheung Wan before splitting up to three locations: the headquarters of the Real Estate Developers Association of Hong Kong in World-Wide House; the Cheung Kong Center of CK Asset Holdings Ltd.; and Group, the head office of Hang Lung Properties Ltd., in the Standard Chartered Bank Building.

9 September     The then-HKSAR Chief Executive Donald Tsang mentioned the labour strike in a meeting with then-Chinese President Hu Jintao in Sydney, Australia.

12 September   A consensus was reached after a seven-hour negotiation between the employers and the workers. The daily wage was increased to HK$860, and the daily work hour was set at eight hours. The bar-bender strike officially came to an end.

紮鐵工潮16年  

6 mins read

2007年的盛夏, 逾千紮鐵工人用淚與汗維權,為香港工運寫下新篇章。歷時36天的紮鐵工潮,是2013年碼頭工潮以外,香港最大規模的罷工。16年過去,本港工會運動陷入前所未見的低潮,紮鐵工潮值得記取的不僅是工人工資有多少升幅、工時減了多少,更重要是為日後連場工運起了示範作用,特別在今時今日的政治寒冬下,回顧當年一役,更有啟發。

由8月8日到9月12日……

2007年8月,本港爆發歷時36天的紮鐵工潮。200名紮鐵工人當年今日在土瓜灣天光道豪宅地盤發起罷工,要求改善1997年後不斷倒退的薪酬待遇,為工潮揭開序幕。1997年,紮鐵工日薪達1200元,日做8小時,但經歷金融風暴及沙士後,到2007年人工跌至800元,每日開工8.5小時。為爭取合理權益,工人發起罷工,要求日薪950元,並回復8小時工作,但香港建築扎鐵商會拒絕。資方有恃無恐,壓搾基層,長期訴求被無視,工人怒火一發不可收拾。

紮鐵工薪酬待遇過去一直靠工聯會旗下香港建造業扎鐵職工會與商會磋商,該會當時是業界唯一工會,故工潮初期也是由工聯會主導。8月13日,扎鐵職工會與資方代表談判,商會僅承諾將日薪上調至850元,翌年再增至950元,談判破裂,工會代表卻呼籲工人散去,結束罷工,工人怒轟工聯會出賣工人。

反觀職工盟一直與罷工工人同行,工聯會離場後,職工盟協助選出工人代表,運動模式開始轉變,由工人主導運動,工會從旁協助策劃抗爭行動,爭取公眾支持。高峰期有超過80個地盤的工人響應,地盤施工陷於癱瘓。最後勞資拉鋸36日,終在9月12日達成共識,工潮正式落幕。

撐到底的堅持 

職工盟在工潮期間策劃過兩次大規模遊行,分別有1500人與2500人參加,其他集會更是多不勝數「罷工,撐到底!」、「紮鐵佬,係好漢;冇我哋,冇繁榮!」、「擔得起條鐡,擔唔起頭家」…….這些極具創意的口號及標語,到今時今日大家仍記憶猶新。

紮鐵工最終成功爭取加薪至860元,較商會最初提出的加幅多十元,但紮鐵工潮的意義遠多於十元加幅。是次工潮確立了紮鐵工每天工作8小時的安排,工友在工潮過去又自組「紮鐵業團結工會」,與工聯會的扎鐵職工會分庭抗禮,每年與商會磋商工人薪酬安排,工人議價能力有所提升,至去年紮鐵熟練技工日薪現已增至2600元。

成碼頭工潮的啟蒙 

紮鐵工潮期間,職工盟首次成立罷工抗爭基金,透過眾籌支援罷工工友,36天的紮鐵工潮匯集了社會各界支持,其後40多個團體組成「各界支援紮鐵工潮聯合陣線」,不同團體輪流向地產商會請願,形成了一股強勁民間力量。36天的紮鐵工潮成功連結香港工運和社運,更獲國際工會聲援,紮鐵工人的抗爭經驗亦成為2013碼頭工潮,以及2017年海麗邨清潔工工潮的借鏡。

前職工盟秘書長李卓人於8月19日紮鐵工首次遊行時曾說過:「大家鬥長命,最後一定係我哋勝利。」當時工潮只是初期,資方對工人訴求無動於衷,但工人們眾志成城,終在工潮中取得勝利。今天縱然港人處於劣勢,威權政府用盡各種手段打壓異己,但歷史告訴我們,水滴石穿,我們要學習紮鐵工人的堅毅:「最後一定係我哋勝利」。

2007紮鐵工潮36日事件簿 

日期 事件 
8月8日 200紮鐵工人首度集會,在土瓜灣靠背壟道地盤外罷工,要求日薪由800元加至950元,並減工時至每天8小時,資方拒絕 
8月9日 500人集會,其中200人到禮賓府示威,20多人衝擊商會辦公室 
8月10日 600工人在8號風球下遊行到中環,被警方阻止,轉往油麻地地鐵站靜坐3小時 
8月11日 時任勞工及福利局局長張建宗連日拒絕接見名工人,300人衝出皇后大道中及雪廠街堵塞馬路,癱瘓交通3小時 
8月13日 工會聯會旗下扎鐵職工會早上與建築扎鐵商會談判,商會同意將日薪增至850元,翌年8月再加至950元,並每日早上增15分鐘休息時間,但工人不收貨,談判破裂,工聯會代表呼籲工人散去,被斥出賣工人 
8月19日 職工盟發起示威,1500人遊行到政府總部抗議 
8月20日 職工盟宣布成立支援紮鐵工人基金,呼籲市民捐款 
8月24日 罷工支援基金籌得46萬,1200罷工工人每人獲分300元 
8月25日 40多個團體組成「各界支援紮鐵工潮聯合陣線」 
8月26日 2500人遊行撐罷工,喚起國際工會關注 
8月31日 重開談判,未能達成共識,工人代表拉隊離場 
9月2日 工人再到政府總部靜坐 
9月3日 工人繼續示威,在勞工處位於上環的總部出發,兵分三路,分別到地產建設商會總部的環球大廈、長實集團的長江中及恆隆地產總部的渣打銀行大廈外示威 
9月9日 時任特首曾蔭權在澳洲悉尼與國家主席胡錦濤會面時提及工潮 
9月12日 勞資經7小時談判達成共識,日薪加至860元,每日工作8小時,歷時36日工潮結束